Short selling is a trading strategy where you bet against a stock, profiting if its price falls. While this might sound appealing, short selling comes with significant risks and costs that make it unsuitable for most traders. This article explains how short selling works and why we recommend avoiding it.
Warning: Short Selling is Very Risky
Short selling involves borrowing shares and paying fees to your broker. You face unlimited loss potential since a stock can rise indefinitely, and you must pay borrowing fees for as long as you hold the position. We recommend most traders avoid short selling entirely.
What is Short Selling?
Short selling is selling a stock you do not own with the intention of buying it back later at a lower price. You borrow shares from your broker, sell them immediately at the current market price, and then aim to buy them back cheaper. The difference between your selling price and buying price is your profit - minus the fees you pay.
Simple version: Sell high, buy low. Instead of the normal buy low, sell high. You borrow shares, sell them now, and hope to return them later after buying them back at a lower price. But you pay fees to borrow those shares the entire time.
How Short Selling Works Step by Step
- Borrow shares from your broker: Your broker lends you shares from their inventory or from other customers who hold the stock.
- Sell the borrowed shares: You sell these shares at the current market price. The cash goes into your account.
- Wait for the price to drop: If you are right, the stock price declines.
- Buy to cover: You buy the same number of shares at the lower price to return to your broker.
- Pay all fees: Your profit is the selling price minus the buying price, minus borrowing fees, interest, and any dividends paid.
Example of a Short Sale
You think stock ABC is going to fall from its current price of $100.
- You borrow 100 shares and sell them at $100 each
- You receive $10,000 in your account
- The stock drops to $80 per share over 30 days
- You buy 100 shares at $80 to return to your broker
- You spend $8,000 to close the position
- Gross profit: $10,000 - $8,000 = $2,000
- But: You paid $50 in borrowing fees over 30 days
- Actual profit: $1,950
And if the stock went UP to $120 instead, you would lose $2,000 PLUS the borrowing fees - and the loss could be much worse if the stock kept rising.
The Costs of Short Selling
Short selling is expensive. These costs eat into your profits and make short selling much harder than simply buying stocks:
1. Borrowing Fees
You pay interest to borrow the shares. Easy to borrow stocks might cost 0.25% to 1% annually. Hard to borrow stocks can cost 20%, 50%, or even more per year. These fees are charged daily and add up quickly.
2. Dividend Liability
If the stock pays a dividend while you are short, you must pay that dividend to the lender. This comes directly out of your pocket.
3. Margin Interest
Short selling requires a margin account. If you use borrowed money to fund your short, you pay additional interest on that as well.
4. Trading Costs
You pay commission fees when you sell short and again when you buy to cover.
Borrowing Fees Add Up Fast
If a stock has a 30% annual borrow rate and you hold a $10,000 short position for 3 months, you would pay approximately $750 just in borrowing fees. This is money lost regardless of whether your trade is profitable.
Why Short Selling is Dangerous
Short selling has unique risks that make it more dangerous than buying stocks:
1. Unlimited Loss Potential
When you buy a stock, the most you can lose is 100% of your investment if it goes to zero. When you short a stock, your losses are theoretically unlimited because a stock can rise infinitely. A $10 stock could become $100, $500, or more.
2. Short Squeezes
When a heavily shorted stock rises, shorts rush to cover their positions, pushing the price higher and causing more covering. This creates a feedback loop that can send prices skyrocketing. Many traders have been wiped out by short squeezes.
3. Margin Calls
If the stock rises and your equity falls below maintenance requirements, you must add funds or close the position immediately - often at the worst possible time when prices are high.
4. Recall Risk
The lender can demand their shares back at any time, forcing you to cover even if you do not want to.
5. Time Works Against You
With a long position, you can wait indefinitely for a stock to rise. With a short position, you are paying borrowing fees every day. Time is your enemy.
Why We Recommend Against Short Selling
We advise most traders to avoid short selling for these reasons:
- Unlimited loss potential: You can lose more than your entire investment
- Constant fee drain: Borrowing fees eat into returns every day
- Timing pressure: You cannot simply wait for your thesis to play out
- Margin requirements: Requires a margin account with additional risks
- Market bias: Historically, stocks tend to rise over time, working against short sellers
- Psychological burden: Watching unlimited loss potential creates enormous stress
Better Alternatives
If you believe a stock will decline, consider these alternatives that have defined risk:
1. Buy Put Options
A put option gives you the right to sell a stock at a specific price. Your maximum loss is limited to the premium you paid. No borrowing fees, no margin calls, and no unlimited loss potential.
2. Sell Covered Calls
If you own shares and think they might decline or stay flat, selling covered calls generates income while you hold the position.
3. Simply Stay on the Sidelines
If you think a stock is overvalued, the simplest strategy is to not own it and wait for better opportunities. You do not have to be in every trade.
Our Recommendation: If you want to profit from a stock decline, buying put options is far safer than short selling. Your loss is limited to what you paid for the option, you pay no borrowing fees, and you cannot receive margin calls.
Understanding Short Interest Data
Even if you do not short sell, understanding short interest can be useful for analyzing stocks:
- Short interest: The total number of shares currently sold short. High short interest means many traders are betting against the stock.
- Short ratio (days to cover): Short interest divided by average daily volume. It tells you how many days it would take for all shorts to cover at normal trading volume.
High short interest can indicate that a stock is ripe for a short squeeze if good news comes out and shorts scramble to cover.
Track Your Trading Performance
Pro Trader Dashboard helps you monitor all your trades and analyze your performance. See your profit and loss across all positions with detailed analytics.
Summary
Short selling lets you profit when stock prices fall, but it comes with significant risks and costs. The unlimited loss potential, constant borrowing fees, margin requirements, and short squeeze risk make short selling unsuitable for most traders. If you believe a stock will decline, buying put options is a safer alternative with defined risk. We recommend most traders avoid short selling and focus on strategies where the risk is limited to their investment.
Ready to learn more? Check out our guide on put options for a safer way to profit from declining stocks, or read about risk management basics to protect your trading capital.